Aereo and the chilling effect

It’s not unusual for both sides to kick up the rhetoric during a contentious court case. Such has been the case with Aereo, which will soon defend its right to continue offering its service before the U.S. Supreme Court. Should it win, broadcasters such as CBS and Fox have vowed that they will take their programming off the air and distribute only through cable, That’s a tantalizing option for those who would like to see such prime spectrum reallocated to wireless data.

A defeat for Aereo would be a loss for consumers, but the chilling effect would be limited. Aereo’s service, of course, applies only to broadcast television and the specific legal issue revolves around the legality of having a remote antenna sending OTA broadcasting over broadband. When one considers the future of television, it seems pretty certain that OTA will give way to native IP streaming of some sort. Consumers want to hold on to as much right to view content as they see fit. But if one wants the functionality of Aereo, there are marketplace alternatives that don’t face such legal challenges.

HTC One’s Dot View is a case of love quickly lost

The new HTC One has a lovely profile and design, but the latest version of Sense remains as polarizing as ever. In almost every case, one can see why HTC chose to implement what it implemented, and the narrower font can be helpful, but rarely is it better and in some cases it’s worse. BlinkFeed isn’t a bad app, but does it really need to be one of the home screens?

The signature accessory for the smartphone is the HTC Dot View which, from a casual look at its operation, might lead one to believe is loaded with LEDs. It’s not and is a surprisingly low-tech affair like the many flat cases for the Galaxy handsets and from third parties for the iPhone. The main problem with the case is that it fails to wrap tightly around the One’s curved back, making the grip of the phone with its screen exposed a bit more awkward that it should be. Of course, you could also let the flap dangle, but that can also be awkward. As for the Dot View display, the functionality is offered via the One’s naked display and in better graphic quality.

Amazon not Fired up about entering the console race

Over at Engadget, Ben Gilbert notes that Amazon isn’t trying to create a console with its svelte new Fire TV. Indeed, despite long-running proclamations by the Xbox team about how much non-gaming applications account for the console’s usage , roughly 80 percent of a console’s value proposition comes down to its gaming. The remainder down to entertainment, mostly broadband video. Why? Because it’s silly to pay $400 for a box that can deliver the same (or less) broadband content than an Apple TV or Roku that costs a quarter of the price or less.

The Fire TV, of course, hits that lower price, but with more impressive specs, and Amazon is putting that extra horsepower to work on games. Indeed, the Fire TV controller is a separate purchase, which helps the retailer create a higher-value microconsole proposition than entrants such as the crowddfunded OUYA (now retreating from hardware) and GameStick. But the real advantage to the positioning is that Amazon gets to mitigate its risk in the unproven territory of casual gaming TV boxes, a frontier that Roku had set out to conquer with the otherwise successful Roku 3. That said, Amazon has assets here that Roku never had and continues to lack.

No, the Fire TV is not a console. In fact, it turns the relative games-video value proposition of a console upside down.

The Xperia Z2: Sony’s prelude to progress

The release of the new HTC One has served as a reminder of the company’s struggles to make market headway despite nearly universally praised designs.

But there is another company struggling with that predicament that has a long history to the contrary: Sony. Its XPERIA handsets are solid, attractive, have gorgeous displays, great cameras and were water-resistant before it was cool. The company continued its flagship back at MWC with the XPERIA Z2, one of the first handsets to include Qualcomm’s Quick Charge 2.0 technology.

That Sony, which has a great tradition of battery technology including rapid charging, adopted the technology is a significant endorsement of its value. The company is still not pushing hard in the U.S. – probably a wise move considering its restructuring and the highly competitive environment. However, should it change its mind as it ramps up to a six-month release cycle, it would be coming in with a strong offering.

iWork updates are no April Fools’ joke

The release of Office for iPad motivated me to take a second look at iWork. Today I downloaded Numbers, which was the only of the three that I hadn’t previously used. I grabbed Numbers because I needed to work with a multisheet spreadsheet and most of the inexpensive and free integrated iPad suites I tried couldn’t handle it. Documents To Go, an old favorite, was particularly disappointing since it crashed. But Numbers handled it beautifully. And then, not a few hours after I downloaded Numbers, Apple updated the entire suite to Version 2.2 with significant improvements including, for example, the ability for Keynote to export to PowerPoint .pptx format. Touche!

How good is iWork compared to Office for iPad? Really good, even at the old price of $30 for the suite So good, in fact, that Microsoft isn’t even really trying to compete directly. Office for iPad is really well done and surely a solid preview of what lies ahead for Windows, but so much of the value of the subscription really makes sense only if you’re in the Microsoft ecosystem. Kudos to Microsoft for writing a great set of applications for the iPad while tackling its monetization issue, but it sure isn’t going to expand its footprint meaningfully off its home turf.

Quick Charge 2.0 won’t lead to a standards war

In my recent column for CNET, I discussed Quick Charge 2.0, the proposed standard from Qualcomm (a client of Reticle Research) that promises to dramatically improve charging time for smartphones and tablets. Quick Charge is pretty exciting for people who find themselves fighting for a few precious minutes of juice at a spare outlet throughout the day or who want to avoid having to keep a power stick awkwardly connected to their phone for too long.

As I mention in the column, greater power via the USB connector is also coming via the USB Implementer Forums’ Power Delivery (PD) initiative and has the potential to finally standardize connectors across virtually all devices within the home. But there are some drawbacks. PD adapters require new USB cables and could be larger depending on how much power they deliver.

A blessing and burden of being so close to the center of the mobile universe as Qualcomm is that it must often consider or even support competing standards even as it advocates its own. The company has shown this with its support of multiple wireless charging standards and there’s no reason we couldn’t see similar coexistence with both technologies operating over the same charging accessories.

Where will it all shake out? One likely scenario is to think of Quick Charge as being focused on devices that use USB connectors now (mostly smartphones and tablets) and PD as bringing larger devices into the USB connector fold. We saw some excitement around this with the HP Chromebook that Google promoted last year.

With more devices supporting both standards, consumers can one day look forward to bringing one charger and cable with them that will work with everything from their smartphone to their laptop . But until that day, there’s no need to hold back getting more juice to the mobile devices that need it most urgently today.

Samsung’s Pro tablets go big, leave home, have consumer relevance

Mobile World Congress will soon be upon us and will surely bring with it news of tablets that was mostly missing from CES despite such products continuing to be among the hottest categories in consumer electronics. One exception to the dearth of CES announcements was the Samsung 12″ Galaxy Tab Pro and Galaxy Note Pro. The Pro” sub-subbrand takes over from the “Note” subbrand as Samsung’s most premium denotation, leaving Note to just represent pen input. To contrast, pen input is part of what differentiates Microsoft’s Surface Pro, but of course has nothing to do with the MacBook Pro.

The Pro line will also mark the debut of Samsung’s first Android tablets to break the 12″ barrier. In 2012, Toshiba reached well beyond that barrier with the 13.3″ Excite, but the pricey product vanished soon after it was released. The Samsung device is not only smaller, but thinner and lighter — a key advantage when dealing with a larger tablet.

The big Pro tablets are Samsung’s Android play to eat into a bit of the market for Windows and Chrome notebooks for on-the-go productivity. The company highlights the extended comfortable soft keyboard on the big screen. It also seeks to position the big tablet as supporting multiple open Android applications, a multitasking feature that allows Android tablets to better answer the functions of Windows. Paradoxically, this occurs as Windows is moving toward reducing the number of apps that can be on the screen at one time, at least in its Modern interface.

But the larger screen should yield content consumption benefits as well, particularly for applications such as playing games and movies, reading magazines and sheet music. It’s doubtful it will do much to stem the glut of 7″ devices that have democratized the Android tablet. But it could help push Android into a screen size where there have been few altenratives for those valuing screen size over portability.

Taking wireless charge at Apple

Wireless power accessory maker WiQiQi is offering an adapter for the iPhone that enables it to work with Qi wireless chargers. Unlike many such adapter cases that extend the bottom of the iPhone in order to , it slips unobtrusively into the Lightning connector and bends to the back of the iPhone so that you’d hardly know it was there if you had the iPhone in a slim opaque case — that is, unless, you tried plugging something into the Lightning port, which can accommodate only one connector at a time.

From a usability standpoint, Apple’s not down with Qi for reasons that are likely similar to its aversion to NFC, that is, having to keep the phone in one place. In Qi’s case, the argument goes, if you’re going to lay it resting somewhere, you may as well plug it in. Also, as with NFC, the phone has to be in a specific orientation for the charging to work. Of course, we are all holding out for true  ubiquitous wireless electricity.

Indulging in a bit of sci-fi, the company could achieve a coup if it could develop some way that the entire surface and sides of, say, an iPhone or iPad could be accept a charge. This would allow it to charge by placing it on an easel-like stand the way the TouchPad was able to, or charge by being in a clamshell-type case like one for the Brydge iPad keyboard. In addition, if small bits of data could be transferred this way, it would allow Apple to outdo Surface. You could snap on a keyboard cover to either side or attach the power cable to virtually any part of the device. Ladies and gentlemen, start your patent applications.

Surface off a surface: better but still not great

With its signature keyboard cover detached, it was easy to use the original Surface RT in your lap. However, actually trying to type with the device while it was positioned there could end with your Surface hitting the lowest surface in the immediate vicinity, often the one at your feet. It was simply too easy for the weight of the device to overwhelm the high center of gravity that the Surface had when resting on its kickstand, particularly on an uneven sloping landscape, e.g., one’s lap.

It’s a bit surprising that Microsoft would implement a second kickstand position that extends its already larger-than-laptop footprint when the keyboard cover is extended. However, it has done just this in the name of better stability, particularly when used in that common scenario that gives that laptop its name. The result has been an improvement when used in the lap as the lower center of gravity helps with stability.

However, it’s still not as stable an experience as a laptop. The keyboard cover’s connection to the tablet does not cover the device’s width and its rubbery texture allows for a lot of give. As a result, there’s a good chance you’ll notice the screen to tilt to a slight angle off from where you’re typing. Customers may not find this so distracting, but it drives home the point that there continue to be some things that the trusty old clamshell form factor handles better than the type cover.

That said, newer designs like those on the Dell Venue Pro 11 and Nokia Lumia 2520 rely on a type cover on which the entire tablet rests and where there is no gap in terms of the footprint as there is with the Surface’s kickstand, so lap stability may be better.

Speed bumps in binging on This American Life

I’ve been on the hunt for more audio content lately so I picked up the This American Life Android app, which enables easy access to every episode — 500+ hours — of the public radio programming  dating back to 1995. (In the second episode, a new color Macintosh portable is referenced.) Assuming you like the show, it’s a great value — less than 3/5 of a cent per episode and dropping as new ones become available.

The app can automatically download the latest episode of the show, which makes sense for those current with the program, but otherwise limits you to one other downloaded episode. This isn’t a great option for those new to the show and listening to the episodes in chronological order. (Speaking of which, an episode sorting feature would be nice.)

Admittedly, it might be impractical to download the entire library, but one episode isn’t enough to cover some commutes, much less many short flights. I can’t imagine what technical limitation there might be to enabling one to download, say, three to five episodes at a time. Hopefully, the developers aren’t thinking about saving this feature for some in-app purchase.